tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5379693993565829338.post2791734669922787887..comments2023-07-04T09:58:36.468+08:00Comments on Total Film (Wordy): HKIFF 2009 之 14:捷古華拉Wordyhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/08457516587590450245noreply@blogger.comBlogger4125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5379693993565829338.post-2102295345939479852009-04-12T18:18:00.000+08:002009-04-12T18:18:00.000+08:00sonus_cat:我覺得《橫山家之味》還行,《阿房》就真有點失望。反正那本來是電視劇,不能以電影標...sonus_cat:<br>我覺得《橫山家之味》還行,《阿房》就真有點失望。反正那本來是電視劇,不能以電影標準來評的<br><br>Matt,<br>Yes, we have intermission here between part 1 and 2. I can stand a 170-min movie. Not all battles or events depicted in the movie are essential, and I think part 1 looks more interesting than 2 as the linkage between the 2 parts are not very clear.Wordyhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/08457516587590450245noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5379693993565829338.post-63922545566863649112009-04-11T05:08:00.000+08:002009-04-11T05:08:00.000+08:00Just curious, was there intermission in HK? I saw...Just curious, was there intermission in HK? I saw it last night and there was a 10-minute break halfway. I shouldn't have seen it during the week.... :P<br><br>The film could have been done in like 2 hours.Matthttp://mattviews.wordpress.comnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5379693993565829338.post-50086113847985248402009-04-10T20:44:00.000+08:002009-04-10T20:44:00.000+08:00寫得太亂......寫錯東西.....[我習慣寫一堆詞語,再重組句子。]不過,《捷古華拉》是否真的需...寫得太亂......寫錯東西.....<br>[我習慣寫一堆詞語,再重組句子。]<br><br>不過,《捷古華拉》是否真的需要<br>兩個部分4小時半? 它其實是可以<br>處理得精簡一些。<br>[相反,《牯嶺街少年殺人事件》<br>一處都不可剪,這樣的篇幅才反映<br>台灣那個時代的悲情。]<br><br>比較深刻是《捷古華拉》臨死和<br>兵丁那段對話。人物描寫都有用心,<br>例如上半集有一個很攪笑的瘦兵丁,<br>女角都ok深刻。當然可以再深刻一些,但想起千人一面的電影 Milk,<br>《捷古華拉》角色處理上始終多很<br>多detail。<br><br>雖然如此,但今年得《捷古華拉》<br>+ 《河上的愛情》是收貨。<br>《阿房》、《橫山家之味》<br>、《虛擬虛憶》都幾令我失望。sonus_catnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-5379693993565829338.post-37492446089469540522009-04-10T20:36:00.000+08:002009-04-10T20:36:00.000+08:00其實單計時間4小時半是ok,之前看satantango[7小時],牯嶺街少年殺人事件都要4小時。不過...其實單計時間4小時半是ok,<br>之前看satantango[7小時],<br>牯嶺街少年殺人事件都要4小時。<br><br>不過,《捷古華拉》是否真的需要<br>4小時半? 它其實是可以處理得精簡一些<br>。[相反,《牯嶺街少年殺人事件》<br>一處都不可剪,這樣的篇幅才反映<br>台灣那個時代的悲情。]<br><br>比較深刻是《捷古華拉》臨死和<br>兵丁那段對話。人物描寫都有用心,<br>例如上半集有一個很攪笑的瘦兵丁,<br>兩個女角都ok深刻。當然可以再深刻一些,但想起千人一面的電影 Milk,<br>《捷古華拉》角色處理上始終多很<br>多detail。<br><br>雖然如此,但今年得《捷古華拉》<br>+ 《河上的愛情》是收貨。<br>《阿房》、《橫山家之味》<br>、《虛擬虛憶》都幾令我失望。sonus_catnoreply@blogger.com